People’s assemblies the crucial lifeline that democracy needs

Published in the Vancouver Sun.

Sonia Furstenau and Maeve Maguire: In response to the animosity and apathy toward the democratic process that many Canadians might have once believed in, there is a growing movement to change the game

Democracy in Canada needs a lifeline.

Fortunately, there are countless organizations and individuals determined to keep it afloat. The B.C. Legislature’s Special Committee on Democratic and Electoral Reform, which released its report last month, received input from nearly 1,000 participants — individuals and groups who care enough to do exactly what democracy requires of us: show up.

The summaries of what the committee heard are a collection of solutions that would revitalize, strengthen, and reimagine our democracy — at just the moment when we need to do exactly this work.

The problem

The warning signs in Canada are there. Evidence is clear that there is a concentration of power in the Prime Minister’s Office, which restricts elected officials from the decision-making process. The outcome is that those who we elect to represent our interests in Ottawa have limited ability to influence policies that affect our communities. As power is concentrated, the public’s voice is weakened.

In B.C., it’s a similar story. Election promises made by partisan candidates are forgotten when elected into ministerial roles. The combative nature of dialogue inside the legislature hinders collaboration and consensus building on crisis-level issues, including climate change and public health policies.

In local government, you need only go to a public hearing for a community’s official community plan to see the decay in public engagement. Familiar speakers stand at the microphone commenting on how they feel unheard in local policy decisions. These meetings are not inclusive, there is no deliberation, and the tone is contentious. Few people participate in public hearings because they rarely change the outcome of the council’s stated direction. Who would leave the house for that?

The public is restless and seeking hope. In response to the animosity and apathy toward the democratic process that many Canadians might have once believed in, there is a growing movement to change the game.

A solution: people’s assemblies

One game changer, recommended by the committee, is a people’s assembly. An assembly is a group of randomly selected community members who reflect the region’s demographic and social diversity. The assembly is asked to research a challenging policy issue. Over the course of several months, these community members gain a deep understanding of the causes and effects of the problem, and make recommendations to the government on how to move forward on that issue. Unlike partisan debate, the process informs the assembly and the broader community, which translates into informed opinions and mutual respect.

These public participation systems are being used around the world, with extraordinary success in some cases. Citizens’ assemblies in Ireland led to two significant policy changes in the last decade: legalized same-sex marriage, and removing a constitutional ban on abortion.

Municipalities are using the assembly model to guide policy-making. Burnaby and Gibsons used residents’ assemblies to provide guidance for official community plans, giving community members the ability to give informed input at the beginning of the planning processes. This is a stark contrast to the typical approach, in which residents come to a public hearing at the final stage of the process, often expressing their frustration and anger.

Saanich and Victoria hosted an assembly to investigate the question of amalgamation. The assembly released a report recommending the municipalities amalgamate — the referendum question will be on the ballot in the next municipal election. New Westminster has created a standing community assembly with 36 members, randomly selected each year, to advise council on actions related to council’s strategic priorities.

The authors of the Clean B.C. review, released last month, recommended that the provincial government create a citizens’ assembly on a sustainable economy.

Assemblies are a powerful means of strengthening our democratic landscape. They bring people together to investigate important issues, build common and reliable knowledge, and engage in constructive dialogue and deliberation. The process begins with finding shared values, and members of assemblies consistently report on the feelings of connection and belonging that develop through the process. In a time of polarization, assemblies remind us all that we have shared interests, goals, and hopes, and that when we create the space for understanding different perspectives and collaborating on solutions, we are building democratic muscle and stronger communities.

In the spirit of public participation in democracy, we can change the game together. We can start by demanding that the government use the assembly model in decision making. We strengthen democracy by having faith in the wisdom of the people.


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *